Slightly OT: PCIe X16 Card In X8 Slot

Home » CentOS » Slightly OT: PCIe X16 Card In X8 Slot
CentOS 1 Comment

So, in the ongoing saga of the unusual 1U short-depth workstation, we have narrowed the field to two choices. Both entrants are configured with 16GB memory (4x4GB), two 2.5″ drives (1x250GB SSD and 1x1TB HDD), and an NVIDIA NVS510 graphic card (quad display):

1) SuperMicro 5017R-MF, Xeon E5-2609 processor
2) SuperMicro 5017C-LF, Xeon E3-1220 processor

(I wish SuperMicro had a list of their servers by chassis somewhere.)

I have no preference between the solutions for right now, though I have a major concern with the second solution;
the PCIe slot is only x8, and the NVS510 is a x16 card. The vendor assures me that a riser/adapter can be found to plug the card into the slot, and that it will work, but I am highly concerned about the performance. I know nothing about PCIe (I haven’t built a system in 10 years, though I
have read the PCIe Wikipedia entries and some guides);
what kind of performance hit can I expect?

Also, are there any solutions I have overlooked?

Thanks again,
-G.

One thought on - Slightly OT: PCIe X16 Card In X8 Slot

  • So, in the ongoing saga of the unusual 1U short-depth workstation, we have narrowed the field to two choices. Both entrants are configured with 16GB memory (4x4GB), two 2.5″ drives (1x250GB SSD and 1x1TB HDD), and an NVIDIA NVS510 graphic card (quad display):

    1) SuperMicro 5017R-MF, Xeon E5-2609 processor
    2) SuperMicro 5017C-LF, Xeon E3-1220 processor

    (I wish SuperMicro had a list of their servers by chassis somewhere.)

    I have no preference between the solutions for right now, though I have a major concern with the second solution;
    the PCIe slot is only x8, and the NVS510 is a x16 card. The vendor assures me that a riser/adapter can be found to plug the card into the slot, and that it will work, but I am highly concerned about the performance. I know nothing about PCIe (I haven’t built a system in 10 years, though I
    have read the PCIe Wikipedia entries and some guides);
    what kind of performance hit can I expect?

    Glenn,

    You choices are pretty much equal, although the 5017R-MF has the slower processor, but larger cache. Both have four core CPUs.

    I recommend going with the native PCIe x16 slot to take full advantage of the NVS510, especially if you are going to run four heads and your application is graphic intensive.

    Regards,

LEAVE A COMMENT